Madden NFL 26 Review

Madden NFL 26 raises the bar with gameplay improvements, dynamic play-calling options, and a massive franchise overhaul, my full review.

Madden NFL 26 arrives at a pivotal moment for EA Sports, with the long-awaited return of College Football tightening the bridge between the college game and the pros. As someone who has lived and breathed football sims since the Tecmo Bowl days, I came into this year’s installment with equal parts excitement and skepticism. Thankfully, EA Tiburon took the ball and ran with it, delivering its best gridiron performance yet.

"EA Tiburon took the ball and ran with it, delivering its best gridiron performance yet."

Madden NFL 26 may not reinvent the entire playbook, but it pushes the franchise forward with purpose, polish, and energy, standing as the strongest entry in the series in years. Let’s break things down play-by-play in my Madden 26 review.

Madden NFL 26 Details

Platform(s): Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5, PC, Nintendo Switch 2

Reviewed on: Xbox Series X and PS5 Pro

Developer: EA Tiburon / EA Orlando

Publisher: EA Sports

Genre: Sports

Available game modes: Franchise, Superstar (player career), Ultimate Team (MUT), Online head-to-head, Quickplay, Skills Trainer

ESRB Rating: E (Everyone)

Madden NFL 26 Gameplay Improvements

This year, Madden 26 leans more into refinement than reinvention. The foundation is familiar, but the small changes add up to create a much better football experience. The first thing I noticed right away was that the game felt much faster and more fluid.

"The first thing I noticed right away was that the game felt much faster and more fluid."

Movement is sharper, reads are crisper, and on-the-fly decision-making feels more rewarding. Many of the ideas from College Football 26, such as dynamic substitutions and improved control over defensive zones, have been incorporated into Madden, making the pro game feel more innovative and more strategic.

Ball in Air Sees Big Improvements

One of my favourite changes is how passes in the air are handled; defenders now actually have to see the ball before they can react. Gone are the days of defenders swatting or intercepting a pass while looking the other way. That simple fix alone makes things feel far more authentic and less frustrating. I also really appreciated the ability to tweak the depth of defensive zones more precisely, adding new layers of strategy.

"One of my favourite changes is how passes in the air are handled; defenders now actually have to see the ball before they can react."

Blocking, tackling, and overall physics have been smoothed out, though the game isn’t free from the occasional odd animation or awkward player angle. I did see defenders sometimes misstep or glitch slightly out of position. Still, as someone who wants a football sim to feel as close to the real thing as possible, I was impressed. It’s not a total reinvention, but it’s one of the most meaningful steps forward in years.

A Storm Front Moves In with Madden NFL 26

If there’s one feature that really grabbed me, it’s the weather. Rain, snow, and wind are no longer just background details; they matter. During heavy snow games, I genuinely struggled to see receivers breaking on their routes, and in the rain, I noticed players slipping when footing gave way. I even had one game where my top wideout tripped on a cut route because of a soaked field. It didn’t feel like the game was trying to cheat me; it felt like the kind of chaos that comes with real football in bad conditions, and I loved it.

Visually, the weather looks incredible. Snow builds up, rain pools on the field, and there’s a sense of grit and atmosphere that past Maddens didn’t capture. And beyond looks, it forces you to change how you play: more running plays, safer passes, and a constant awareness of the elements. It’s not perfect; sometimes the weather effects feel slightly exaggerated, but it’s easily the most impactful weather system the series has ever seen.

Madden NFL 26 Presentation Upgrades

For me, sports sims live and die by their presentation. I don’t just want to play football, I want to feel like I’m watching a broadcast unfold. Madden 26 finally delivers on that. From pre-game introductions to halftime breakdowns, the game has never felt more like a Sunday broadcast. Halftime shows, expanded commentary, dynamic scoreboards, and broadcast-style highlights all give it the polish that makes me stop and watch instead of just hammering the “skip” button.

The crowd energy feels more alive, the commentary flows more naturally, and even the cut-scenes in between plays do a better job of building immersion. There are still some clunky menus here and there, but overall, the broadcast feel is better than it’s ever been.

Madden NFL 26 Modes

Modes are where I spend most of my time, and Madden 26 offers a ton of variety. Franchise Mode is hands down the star this year. For the first time in ages, I felt like I was managing a real NFL season. Weekly preparation, balancing player fatigue, and tailoring my strategy added a much-needed layer of depth to the experience. I loved being able to shape my team’s identity week by week.

On the downside, while Coach DNA and player traits are improved, the AI coaches' planning and decision-making are impractical. You’ll get recommendations that feel off, and even the in-game probability of pulling them off is low, so why do these crop up often is a mystery. It’s not a deal breaker, but something that could be improved upon in future.

Become an NFL Superstar

Superstar Mode is solid. It’s deeper than before, with more narrative choices and player development options, but it doesn’t quite reach the same highs as Franchise. It’s fun to dabble in, though, and scratches the itch if you want that player-focused story mode.

Madden NFL 26 Ultimate Team (MUT)

Ultimate Team (MUT) remains the primary online card-collecting mode. I dipped in a bit, and while there are more solo options for players like me who don’t want to spend extra cash, the microtransactions and grind are still very present. It’s a mode that can be fun if you love collecting, but I personally prefer sticking with Franchise.

Skills Trainer Improved in Madden NFL 26

Other modes like quickplay and head-to-head perform as expected, while Skills Trainer is a surprisingly good way to brush up on fundamentals. Overall, the package feels complete, with enough options to keep me playing deep into the season.

Final Thoughts on Madden NFL 26

After pouring dozens of hours into Madden NFL 26 , I can confidently say it’s the best virtual gridiron experience I’ve had in years. The gameplay refinements, the way weather shakes up matches, and the new presentation touches make it feel closer than ever to being inside a real NFL broadcast. Franchise Mode alone makes this year’s entry a must-play if you’ve been waiting for Madden to step up.

It’s not flawless. Bugs pop up, menus can drag, MUT still leans too heavily on microtransactions, and a few long-standing quirks remain. But despite these issues, Madden 26 feels like a significant step forward. It’s the kind of Madden you don’t just play a quick game of, it’s one you want to live in for an entire season.

Madden NFL 26 Pros	Madden NFL 26 Cons
+ Strong, refined core gameplay that feels faster and more responsive	– Occasional odd animations and physics glitches
+ Weather & atmosphere improvements that change how games play	– Menus and UI still feel clunky in places
+ Franchise overhaul adds depth and strategy	– MUT still leans heavily on microtransactions
+ Broadcast presentation finally feels immersive	– Bugs and minor technical hiccups at launch

Overall Assessment of Madden NFL 26

Gameplay: 8.5 / 10

Graphics: 8.0 / 10

Sound / Presentation: 8.0 / 10

Lasting Appeal / Replayability: 7.5 / 10

Madden NFL 26 Overall Rating: 32 / 40 (80%)

Electronic Arts provided a copy of this game to conduct the review.

---

About the Author - Matthew "Dapper Tux" Rondina

Matthew has been involved in all things gaming since the 8-bit era. He is a video game and tech industry veteran who has been passionate about technology and gaming for over 20 years. In addition to being the Managing Editor of dappertux.com, he has bylines with Best Buy, Cineplex Entertainment, Mobile Syrup and Walmart. Follow Matthew’s gaming + tech adventures on multiple social platforms with the handle @dapper_tux via X, Instagram, Threads, TikTok, and join in on the fun!

---

dappertux.com uses affiliate links to provide a way for this website to earn advertising income. The blog may earn a referral commission on purchases made via these links.